On Saturday, a young man from Tulane university, a senior studying cellular/molecular biology, suffered a broken neck, damage to his spinal column and a collapsed lung when he collided with a fellow player in a college football game against Tulsa University.
I wrote this post on Friday night, waiting to publish it on Sunday when people would have more time to read it and would maybe read it while watching a game or two. I didn’t anticipate such a devastating example of what I’m writing about. Thoughts and prayers go out to him and his family.
Unlike a lot of my posts, I’m not here to make a bold statement, or stir up controversy. I’m here to ask a question, and to open up dialogue. There’s a few reasons why: one is because a recent post on faith and science has shown me that some of my readers are willing to comment and have really great things to say.
But I must confess that the reason that I leave this question very open-ended is because I haven’t decided on an answer yet.
I try to keep a very open mind on all matters, whether faith, politics, or what have you. I think it is my responsibility as a free-thinking adult who worships a God so dynamic and who lives in a world so diverse to always be ready for correction, new information, and a better understanding. There are some things I hold very dear, and would take a lot to change my mind on, but for the most part, I consider myself a person who, and respect other people immensely who, are open-minded. That being said, I usually do form an opinion on things, even if it is open to change.
So this is one I haven’t yet formed my opinion on, and I thought I might get the opinion of the community here to think through things I haven’t thought of yet. So what I will do is give my thoughts on the matter, show the progress of thought and the “new information” that I’ve been presented with, and then open up the comments section to settle it.
The first thing you should know is I’m not really a big fan of football. The only sport I go out of my way to watch and follow is NBA Basketball. I know enough about NFL and College Football to hold my own in a conversation, but that’s about all. I’ll watch a game with my friends or family, and I’ll get fired-up if the game is intense, but it’s never truly my activity of choice. What this means for this conversation is that I have very little invested in the answer to this question. I have no traditions or hobbies or loyalties or emotions tied up in this answer. So if that means that my answer is different than your answer, that’s really okay.
And that’s my second important point. I don’t think this is, at all, an issue that needs to uniform for Christians everywhere or be written into doctrine or rulebooks. This is one of those issues that I don’t think is in any way a “clincher” for salvation or even a wholesome Christian ethic. I just think it’s worth thinking and talking about.
Alright. So now let’s actually get to the question. Should Christians support football? And I assure you, this has nothing to do with people wanting to leave church early to catch the afternoon game.
It has everything to do with this article
And since I know most people read through this without clicking links, I’ll summarize the article. (Though if you want to join the conversation in the comments, please read the article because he addresses a lot of the things I’m sure will come up… and it’s short.) It argues that supporting football is supporting an institution that does violence and irreparable damage to people. Anyone who follows sports and athletes after retirement knows that this is true of the sport. Several studies have come out showing that football, uniquely, leaves its life-long players with severe damage that all the money in the world can’t fix. So the article questions whether, as Christians, we ought to support the destruction of life and health simply for our own entertainment. The article anticipates rebuttals highlighting that the players “know what they’re getting into” and are paid handsomely for their pain. But what young person would turn down such money and notoriety at that age for fear of pain later? And, when it really comes down to it, that money comes from the fans in ticket/merch sales and television advertising. The argument could be made that we are paying these men to permanently damage their bodies and put themselves in future agonizing pain simply for our entertainment.
While I’m not sold on the argument, or with the “boycott” reaction, this is something I hadn’t thought of before. By watching, how am I participating? In an economic system like ours, does my viewership equal support for the results? I think it does. But is this an issue worth standing up against? Is this a moral issue? And if it is, what can be done about it? Is education the answer? Should the players be shown warnings of the outcome of the life they’re choosing? More importantly, if they did, would it make any difference to these young people?
This brings up a more important church issue. When and if (“if”, in this circumstance) the church deems that an institution such as football is contrary to the will of God, is the proper reaction then to boycott it or avoid it? You see this all the time, especially in my denomination, the Church of the Nazarene. It used to be that Nazarenes were not allowed to go to the movie theatre. While we all recognize that there is much at the theatre that is contrary to God’s best for the world, we realized over time that boycotting something for Christians not only hurts our witness to the world by setting us apart by rules and “holier-than-thou”, it also loses Church members who are forced to choose. And, on a deeper and more important level, it manages to put a limitation on God, saying that God is unable to speak to us through film, which happens to be a powerful lens to see the world from and to hear the story of God in new ways. No, the proper response is prophetic engagement. One might call it “incarnation”. We model the way Christ entered the world, rather than “boycotting” it, and worked for its good and ultimately saved it. We are called to do the same, even with those institutions we deem as “sinful” or counter to God.
One more thing to add to the conversation: I read this article earlier in the week, and it gives me hope that there is some positive movement on this issue. For those that won’t click, the NFL recently donated $30 MILLION to a health group researching specifically sports/football related injuries, particularly head injuries, the lasting ones that NFL retirees suffer. I wonder what the author of the first article would say in response to this, as his article was written 2 years ago and this is a recent development. I think it makes the NFL much easier to support, since they clearly see this as a major issue. (The article notes that this is the largest donation the NFL has ever given to any organization.)
If you’re anything like me, I’d never even thought of any of this as an ethical issue. But’s that’s how learning and growing works: you’re presented with new information, and you have to see whether it is consistent with that you already believe and know. This new information is stirring the pot, for me at least.
So, time to open it up. What do you all think? Currently, I still watch football (a game is actually on as I write this), because it looks like the sport itself is looking into making it safer in serious ways, and because I’m still unsure of how to respond morally to this situation. That being said, as the situation stands, I don’t think I will let my kids play organized football. While the chances are slim of going professional, I wouldn’t want to have to put them in a position to get seriously injured or have to choose between millions of dollars/fame and agony later on. I see this as no different than not allowing my child to become a UFC fighter or boxer.
The question then to answer: In light of the long-term violence and suffering caused on its participants, should Christians engage in football as a form of entertainment, and if so, how?
14 thoughts on “Should Christians Support Football?”
Woah! I’m really enjoying the template/theme of this website.
It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get
that “perfect balance” between usability and appearance. I must say you have done a awesome job with this.
In addition, the blog loads very quick for me on Firefox.
When someone writes an piece of writing he/she maintains the plan of a user in his/her
brain that how a user can understand it. Therefore that’s why
this paragraph is amazing. Thanks!
I am really loving the theme/design of your weblog. Do you ever run into
any web browser compatibility problems? A couple of my blog readers have complained abolut my blog not
working correctly in Explorer but looks great in Safari.
Do you have any solutions to help fix this issue?
It seems funny that I’ll say what I’m about to say, since I’m currently reading a Hauerwaus book on pacifism, but…
There should be some arena where young boys (and girls?) can “mix it up,” to have a chance to practice warrior skills. In American culture, football is one of those arenas, and you can’t get that no matter how good at video games you are.
Now, some would say theology is a contact sport, but that’s a whole ‘nuther conversation.
I would agree that I think sports serve a role in our society as an outlet for aggression and physicality. But at what point do the long-term medical consequences of football in particular cause us to reconsider it specifically as a legitimate version of this?
I suppose everyone needs to answer that question on their own. Really, as soon as you start regulating it, people will cry “Nanny state!” Honestly, I still have problems with kids having to wear helmets whenever riding a bicycle. Honestly, wasn’t this just a ploy for bicycle helmet manufacturers to make a buck?
What if in order to repay athletes for service, we paid them millions of dollars each year? oh wait. . .
What?!? Boxing isn’t major?! ;-)
Congrats on finding a name!
The above comment was by Adam Warner, I guess I need to create an account to show my name. :)
Thanks for the ID :)
Yes, boxing is worse, but I mentioned “major sports”, which boxing no longer is. And driving and biking are not things we pay others to do dangerously for our benefit.
I would be interested to see actual statistics on this. As much as you said “don’t quote me on that”, I have to say the same thing. The only numbers i’ve read are in comparison to other sports, not a percentage of those affected to those not affected.
Does football leave more long-term damages than boxing… I doubt it!! Football is just a sport, let’s try to leave it as a sport. The majority of people who do leave the sport fine (after they are used up) outweigh the amount of people who die or having lasting mental or physical problems. I think, don’t quote me on it!!
Should Christians drive cars? Or just bikes? I know it’s kind of out there but there are many things you can debate over!! :-)
Wow. This is a very controversial issue in my mind. Football, for my family and myself, is a tradition. We’re psycho about it. Bowl games, Superbowl Sunday, even Christmas and Thanksgiving is full of football watching and many times heated, yet respectful, competition. I can’t say I hold an honest opinion on
Whether “Christians” should or shouldn’t watch it. I don’t believe labeling yourself a Christian (or anything else for that matters) should be the reason why you do or do not watch a violent sport. I believe it should be morals and conviction that determines that. Now, that being said. IMO, football is a huge part of my life, dangerous as it may be, I don’t think it’ll ever be less of a part of my life. If people stop watching football because it’s too dangerous, than I also believe hockey and possibly even basketball (which I’ve witnessed can be a dangerous and violent sport) should also be abandoned.
It can’t simply be a matter of “I don’t watch it much, so No people shouldn’t watch it”. It has to be a all or none kind of decision.
I agree with your last point that it shouldn’t be an all or none decision. I tried to make that point somewhere in the middle that even if I decide not to watch it, I won’t judge anyone else for watching it. It’s not that kind of issue.
The reason I singled out football is because the studies are showing that football leaves long term damage moreso than the other sports. Any sport can turn violent because of egos and unruly play, but football’s violence is built-in to the game. If someone gets a concussion or broken rib in basketball, it’s because somebody did something well outside of the rules and probably got ejected from the game for it. In football, players get concussions and broken bones from “good hits”, and are patted on the back and make the highlight reel for it. And hockey… well, no-one watches hockey anyway. Haha.